Facing up to the dashboard metaphor

After about three quarters of an oatmeal stout, my old friend Sam the BI developer wondered aloud, “What is the ideal dashboard?”

There was no need to call Steve Few or Edward Tufte. I had the answer right away. (I had been sipping an oatmeal stout myself.)

The ideal dashboard, I said, is like the human face. You can read the big, obvious signs at a glance: whether the person is smiling, frowning, snarling, or foaming. You know right away whether things are OK.

If things are not OK, you know you’d better ask. That is, you drill down.

If you can’t be direct, you might go on a hunch. “Hmm, looks confused and maybe a little resentful.” Or, in business, you might say, “Hmm, old Charley’s department’s in a muddle about that new hire.”

Even with today’s dashboards, you might have the same insights. But with the face-based display, your intuition would pick up where your rational brain left off—thanks to finer, more subtle, perhaps even ambiguous signals on the first level.

In this model, the dashboard as a metaphor gives way to the face as the guiding light for designers.

Now, hold your applause. There are problems.

For one thing, a face-based display would require a ton more bandwith. Even after designers figured out how to build such a display, engineers would have to pack a lot more data onto the screen.

The bigger problem, I think, is that the business world doesn’t like such soft, gooey metaphors. It prefers metaphors from sports, war and machines.

But once accepted and once the technical part works out, the face metaphor would fit better than the dashboard. After all, what is a business? Is it a machine? Or is it a group of people—with all the flesh and blood and goo and subtlety and amibiguity that that implies?

2 Responses to Facing up to the dashboard metaphor

Leave a reply

Other recent posts

End of one-size-fits-all data stories

This appeared originally on the TDWI site in September behind a paywall. It’s still there, but today they’ve had the 90 days of exclusive use that I agreed to. Survey after survey reveals that about 80 percent of business users don’t use data analysis—despite all the marketing and “easy to use” tools. As if in… Continue Reading

Qlik finally set to leapfrog Tableau?

Who’s your rival? I carelessly asked a Qlik person at the company’s annual analyst reception Monday night in Miami if she hadn’t once worked for Tableau. Her revulsion was immediate. “No! Never!,” she said. We smiled. There was so much more to talk about. For one thing, how will private equity change things? Qlik wasn’t… Continue Reading

Five Tips for Better Data Stories

Originally published on September 22, 2015 in BI This Week, a TDWI publication. A “data story” sounds like such a great idea. You just mix data with storytelling and you’re done — except that most data storytellers get one thing wrong: they drown out the story with data. Such storytellers, I believe, assume that audiences… Continue Reading

Bohemian Grove a la BI

The Bohemian Grove of the BI industry convenes for the fifteenth time in just three weeks. Naturally, you ask the obvious question: Are you serious? The Grove? A summit? The answer begins with a fond recollection of the Grove. If you’ve never attended the Bohemian Grove yourself — I haven’t, though I live in the… Continue Reading